The best sandwich in every New York town
26 sandwiches across 1 New York town. One per shop, and nothing here is ranked against anything else: everything that made it is worth the drive. The verdicts come from the people who eat there, not from critics.
By what you feel like
By county
Every town
All 26 sandwiches
- Pastrami on RyeKatz's Delicatessen · New York
- ProsciuttoCasa Della Mozzarella · Bronx
- Roast BeefBrennan & Carr · Brooklyn
- Bagel with LoxRuss & Daughters Cafe · New York
- Nicky SpecialDefonte's Sandwich Shop · Brooklyn
- Bánh Mì Đặc Biệt (Special Combination)Ba Xuyên · Brooklyn
- Pastrami on Rye2nd Ave Deli · New York
- #1 Grilled Pork Banh Mi (Nem Nuong)Banh Mi Saigon · New York
- Pastrami on RyePastrami Queen · New York
- The No. 7Liebman's Kosher Delicatessen · Bronx
- Banh MiBanh Mi Place · Brooklyn
- Lobster RollGreenpoint Fish & Lobster Co. · Brooklyn
- CubanGuantanamera · New York
- Lobster RollsRed Hook Lobster Pound · Brooklyn
- Johnny RoastbeefJohn's Deli · Brooklyn
- CubanoMargon · New York
- Chopped CheeseBlue Sky Deli (Hajji's) · New York
- The DennisParisi Bakery · New York
- Roll-n-Roast Roast BeefRoll-N-Roaster · Brooklyn
- Uncle JimmyRegina's Grocery · New York
- Pastrami SandwichDavid's Brisket House · Brooklyn
- Superiority BurgerSuperiority Burger · New York
- PinocchioAlidoro · New York
- Tuna MeltS&P Lunch · New York
- The ReubenCourt Street Grocers · Brooklyn
- Falafel SandwichMamoun's Falafel · New York