Best Sandwiches in New York
One sandwich per restaurant, and only S-tier: there is no ranking here because everything that made it is worth the trip. Each one is checked as still open, still on the menu, and vouched for by people who went.
26 sandwiches across 18 neighborhoods
Bedford-Stuyvesant · Bensonhurst · Carroll Gardens · East Harlem · East Village · Flatiron · Greenwich Village · Little Italy · Lower East Side · Midtown · Murray Hill · Nolita · Red Hook · Riverdale · Sheepshead Bay · SoHo · Sunset Park · Upper East Side
- 1Pastrami on RyeKatz's Delicatessen · Lower East Side
- 2ProsciuttoCasa Della Mozzarella ·
- 3Roast BeefBrennan & Carr ·
- 4Bagel with LoxRuss & Daughters Cafe ·
- 5Nicky SpecialDefonte's Sandwich Shop · Red Hook
- 6Bánh Mì Đặc Biệt (Special Combination)Ba Xuyên · Sunset Park
- 7Pastrami on Rye2nd Ave Deli · Murray Hill
- 8#1 Grilled Pork Banh Mi (Nem Nuong)Banh Mi Saigon · Little Italy
- 9Pastrami on RyePastrami Queen · Upper East Side
- 10The No. 7Liebman's Kosher Delicatessen · Riverdale
- 11Banh MiBanh Mi Place ·
- 12Lobster RollGreenpoint Fish & Lobster Co. ·
- 13CubanGuantanamera ·
- 14Lobster RollsRed Hook Lobster Pound ·
- 15Johnny RoastbeefJohn's Deli · Bensonhurst
- 16CubanoMargon · Midtown
- 17Chopped CheeseBlue Sky Deli (Hajji's) · East Harlem
- 18The DennisParisi Bakery · Nolita
- 19Roll-n-Roast Roast BeefRoll-N-Roaster · Sheepshead Bay
- 20Uncle JimmyRegina's Grocery · Lower East Side
- 21Pastrami SandwichDavid's Brisket House · Bedford-Stuyvesant
- 22Superiority BurgerSuperiority Burger · East Village
- 23PinocchioAlidoro · SoHo
- 24Tuna MeltS&P Lunch · Flatiron
- 25The ReubenCourt Street Grocers · Carroll Gardens
- 26Falafel SandwichMamoun's Falafel · Greenwich Village